One Trick Pony Organic Smooth Peanut Butter - 16oz

this is the best peanut butter I've ever had in my life. The jar is bigger than I imagined too

I picked this peanut butter up the other day and it’s delicious! I love that the peanuts are organic and there’s no added oils or sugars. The consistency is pretty runny, but it will be thicker if you store in the fridge. I love the wider opening on the top, however the upside down concept gets messy with the peanut butter being so runny. You end up with peanut butter all on the lid threads and on your countertop. I’d also prefer a glass jar over plastic. Those are my only reasons for removing a star. Again, storing in the fridge will help this issue. This is my favorite peanut butter other than homemade or fresh ground from the health food store.

It’s a fun container and the concept is smart, I gave it a try and we love it! Great for charcuterie boards and on top of burgers!

This is the best peanut butter I’ve ever had!! I do not understand the negative reviews at all unless they’re used to junk peanut butter with added crud in it. This is so creamy and delicious and healthy! No bad oils! Just peanuts and salt! The bottle is unique and does not leak. My kids and I finished this in less than two weeks it’s that good!

Loved the peanut butter but the oil did leaked all over my cabinet

Taste is ok but not thick like peanut butter

I recently purchased the silky smooth peanut butter for the first time. I have grandchildren that love peanut butter. I was pleasantly surprised at how easily I can measure the amount from this container for recipes. I have made PB cookies, PB popsicles and PB & banana oatmeal. The flavor is rich and taste wonderful. I feel good about adding protein to their diets.

smoothest, most delish PB!

I decided to give this a try because I only use natural peanut butters and I'm always looking for one that has a dark roasty flavor and good texture. The happened to be sitting on an end cap and yes the packaging caught my attention so I decided to give it a try. Right away I found fault with the design of the jar because obviously the peanut butter is going to rush to the lid and make a mess when you open it, but you can easily resolve that by just storing it upside down (yes, that defeats the purpose of the jar design, but I'd rather mix in the oil than deal with peanut butter all over the lid every time I open it.) The taste and consistency are okay, I've definitely had better natural peanut butters, and I've had worse. I'd say it ranks somewhere in the middle. But the packaging, while cute and sounds like a great idea in theory because we all hate to have to deal with the oil mix in, this makes absolutely no sense because the peanut butter would be stuck to the lid every time! Like I said, I'll be storing mine upside down, but definitely won't buy this one again. Paying for cute packaging and a gimmick.

So good by picky boys can’t tell the difference from Jif but this is way healthier

Taste great. Doesn’t separate like other natural peanut butters.

The taste of this peanut butter is okay but it's the packaging that I have a problem with. It becomes a sticky, greasy mess over time. It got so bad leaving oil all over my hands and the container, I just gave up and threw it out. And it's also too expensive for what you get. I do not recommend.

You only get half a jar of peanut butter!

Not a full jar. About 1.5cm empty from the top. A little bit too salty. My 6 years old doesn’t prefer it. We bought it to try only coz of the jar is cute, lol!

The peanut butter is good, it does what it says - which is yes you don’t have to stir the oil. But the packaging is flawed; the lid gets SO messy after you open & close it over time. I wouldn’t purchase it again but it was a fun purchase to try

Tastes so fresh. This is such high end fancy peanut butter. I love the fun packaging.

this is literally the best natural minimal-ingredient peanut butter I’ve ever tasted! It reminds me of the peanut butter I had as a child, like traditional brands, but it has no added oils or anything!! just peanuts and salt! I don’t know how they do it but it’s perfect <3 also obsessed with the packaging!

I love it. Very minimal ingredients and tastes great. Love the jar and the cute packaging. Also LOVE that it’s a woman owned/founded company. I knew it was by the cute brand name and label. 🎀

This peanut butter is amazing! I’ve tried all of the no sugar added peanut butters, from JIF and Skippy to the fancy expensive kinds and this one is by far the best! The consistency is perfect, and it only needs a tiny bit of stirring when you first open it, unlike all the other natural peanut butters that are super oily and separated and a big mess. This is not oily at all and is incredibly smooth; it was perfect for drizzling on top of an açai bowl. I saw some complaints about the consistency, so I posted a video and photo to give a better idea of the texture. If you like your peanut butter to be thick, definitely get the crunchy version. Will try it to make fancy PB toast next. Came right back to order the crunchy version!

not silky or smooth. I wouldn't recommend. especially for the price. its a really thick peanut butter. I wouldn't recommend.