Crazy Aaron's Better Butter 3.5" Thinking Putty Tin

my granddaughter loves the smooth squishy feel of this butter putty!

This putty is awful. Gets horribly stuck on hands and is very difficult to get off. It is so runny and immediately went into the trash.

It’s like playing with laffy taffy, not much of a smell, and it’s very stretchy, like play do n slime

The texture and stretchiness of the putty is amazing. However, it comes in a huge tin for $9.99 and there’s the smallest amount of putty in there. You almost need to buy 3 or more of them to have a good amount.

For the price, this product is ridiculous. A huge container for barely any product. Waste of money for sure

Love the texture of this item super soft

The product it’s self is fine. However I’m shocked at the amount of actual butter slime you get in the container! It’s basically empty! Really disappointing.

total disappointment. The container is not even halfway full. Not worth $9.99.

We were excited for this one and there is No way to play with it, it automatically sticks to your hands. We have other Putty from this brand and they are all so perfect. We are super sad how this one turned out.

It came melted a bit and didn’t have very much in it

Within minutes it got super sticky and hard to wash off. The consistency is not what it’s supposed to be like. Very disappointing as my daughter was finally able to get her hands on one just to be let down.

10 dollars for a container less than half way full. Save your money.

Barely any putty in the container. Can was sealed and when opened, less than 1/4 of the space was occupied by the product.

My daughter loves playing with it except if you play with it too long it gets stuck all over your hands, and we had to throw all of it away :( waste of money

Super sticky, horrible stuff. Played with it for about five minutes and it wouldn’t come off our hands.

Amazing!best putty I have EVER touched.very fun and light almost like a slime consistency but very smooth.other reviews on this item that are 1 star is because the putty melted.if you read the box and says to keep in a cool area,this helps it not melt so i recommend keeping it in a cool place

Crazy Aaron’s Putty is basically overpriced wet glue. It’s sticky, messy, gets embedded into everything it touches, and is a nightmare to remove. I’d love to dump a truckload of this stuff in the inventor’s living room and watch them try to clean it out of their carpet and furniture. Whoever designed this either never tested it in a house with kids or has a personal grudge against parents. Save yourself the frustration and don’t buy it. There are plenty of toys that don’t turn your home into a cleanup project.

Not only is the putty catastrophic but customer service exacerbates the deformity. This wasn’t our first Crazy Aaron’s putty, but it will be our last. The putty makes a huge mess and gets stuck in fabrics, clothes, carpet, furniture. Since this isn’t anything like other putty from Aaron’s, I reached out to customer service with photos. They said it was the temp and it would get better after playing with it. WRONG! I thought it was the South’s summer heat, but we left it in its can a couple of days. When we took it out, it appeared to be more like expected. Then after a few squeezes, the nightmare started all over again. Crazy Aaron’s has demonstrated the true meaning behind their name with this one. Making a defective product is one thing, but refusing to take responsibility is crazy.

Awful. I turned around and it was stuck to my daughter’s hands like wet glue. Was impossible to get off and had to remove with paper towels for fear of clogging the sink.

It ended up all over my child's hands. I tried to get it off and it was all over my hands. over an hour and two kids crying and we couldn't salvage a lot of it. It gets everywhere and doesnt come off. its not really something you can actually play with it. its a take the lid off and play with it in the tin.